Monday Musings – Giving Bad Reviews??

My newest segment!! Every Monday, I will post something related to books that has been on my mind lately.

Leaving bad reviews – Do you do it?

This has been a topic of controversy in the book world for years and I don’t see it letting up any time soon. I have been pondering about this for quite awhile and thought I’d share my thoughts with you all today.

It’s no surprise that I am not a stranger when it comes to writing bad reviews. Now, when I say “bad reviews” I don’t mean that my reviews are atrocious (at least I hope they’re not lol). By “bad reviews”, I am speaking in terms of giving negative feedback.

This is a very touchy subject especially among people who are heavily immersed in reading books and, perhaps, even plan on becoming writers themselves.

If you leave a bad review then you are exposing yourself to people who may be overly sensitive when they see that you are basically trashing their favorite novel or their favorite author. Then you have to deal with hoards of fangirls and fanboys everywhere who feel compelled to defend that author/book, but they may not do it in a graceful way.

I have come across a multitude of book reviews on GoodReads and Amazon that did not favor a particular book and they have to defend their reviews against the people who are taking it personally. Those people will behave extremely hostile and cuss and throw insults that have nothing to do with the book! It has gotten so bad that I have known of people who will actually delete their GoodReads accounts, because those same people will not leave them alone. It’s ridiculous!!

On a side note >>> And who could possibly forget about that author who behaved so shamelessly and got upset at a blogger who wrote a bad review and the author basically stalked her to the point of ending up right on her doorstep to confront her. Creepy right? Seriously, who does that besides crazy people in institutions?

I have many friends who love reading, but they hesitate to leave negative reviews because of that very same thing. They don’t want to be targeted. They don’t want to be insulted and so they would rather not say anything at all which saddens me to be perfectly honest.

It saddens me because I feel that everyone is entitled to fully express themselves without being attacked for their opinions. Whether their opinions are praising that book or they’re basically stating that they couldn’t even finish it because it was so bad. It doesn’t matter! No one should feel as if we live in a dictatorship and, god forbid, you say exactly what’s on your mind because then people will retaliate.

So why do I leave negative reviews?

I am compelled to leave a negative review, because I feel that as long as people are not writing reviews at all, or as long as people B.S their way through the review and praise it even though they hated it then the author will never benefit. I get it. Okay? I’m not blinding myself to anything. I know that people want to be considerate and nice. They know that the author spent a lot of time on that novel and it’s basically their baby. I get it.

However, if you do not point out (in a respectful manner) the things that you really disliked about it (grammar, plot holes, etc.) then that author will never know what to work on in the future. They will go on assuming that they are doing just fine because no one tells them the truth. No one gives them an honest account of what they truly think. In this case, giving them a bunch of little white lies is not going to do them any favors when they try and get their work published by an agency.

Leaving negative reviews is not easy. It’s not fun…at all! I don’t enjoy it. I don’t get a rush out of potentially hurting someone’s feelings. I don’t feel good about myself, but I feel that I owe it to myself, I owe it to the author and I owe it to other readers to give my honest opinion. You can tell that many other bloggers or booktubers have experienced some form of hate because right before giving a negative review they will stress the fact that this is only that individual’s opinion and nothing more. It’s crazy that we actually have to give disclaimers so that people will not lose their minds!

I try to lessen the blow by giving some feedback on the things that I DID like. The things that I would love to see more of. In all the years that I have been on GoodReads, I have never had anyone personally attack me for my negative reviews, but I have lost followers and that’s really no concern of mine. You gain some. You lose some. Oh well..(shrugs)

Some people don’t add good feedback to their negative reviews. Some people leave negative reviews that cross an imaginary line. They don’t review the book – oh no – they personally attack the author which I think is absolutely disgusting.

A good way to leave a review on the book you did not like is to concentrate on the parts that killed the mood for you. In other words, you should not write things such as “You should look for another job because you’re not suitable to be an author”. By the way, I actually saw this comment on a very popular author’s GoodReads profile. This is a classic case of a personal attack on the author and it has nothing to do with the book itself. Therefore, you would immediately be deemed a hater not an honest reviewer.

Stick to the facts, include the reasons why you didn’t like the book. Whether it be the prose or perhaps it had too many cliches or maybe you just hated the characters and couldn’t connect with them. Give factual points that helps your readers understand why it didn’t appeal to you.

Those are all the things that people want to read about in the review. Most people do not care how you feel about the authors themselves. They are there searching through all the reviews to decide whether or not to buy the book and that is what you should base your review on. Don’t tear down the writer; concentrate on the story.

There is such a thing as constructive criticism and that should be used instead. If you feel that there are a lot of people in agreement with you then you should point out ways that the writer can improve.

It’s not easy to leave a negative review because regardless of how careful you are, people will interpret things differently and you still may encounter people who fervently disagree with you. And that is okay. You can’t please everyone all of the time.


11 Comments Add yours

  1. Erika says:

    I am not speaking for everyone and only myself but I don’t mind reading negative reviews on books that I enjoyed at all whatsoever. However, the negative reviews that I like to read has to be thorough and well-thought out. I hate reading a bad review when the reviewer just bashes the book and say they hate it because they just do. Your reasons have to be compelling and makes sense.

    I always question when people just says they hate the book…Like you hate it? Why?

    Yes I am also wary posting bad reviews especially when a majority of individuals love the book because I know that there are those who don’t take negative reviews well and get really defensive even when you try to explain it in an appropriate manner compared to those just saying it sucks.

    However, at the end of the day I am entitled to my own opinion and if someone doesn’t like my review or “hate” me for it I shrug it off since it’s so unnecessary to get defensive over something so trivial. It’s not the end of the world if someone doesn’t like the same book as you. *sighs*

    Haha sorry I think I wrote an essay. It makes an interesting discussion.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. lol it really does which is why I wrote a much longer blog than I thought it would be lol and I completely agree with you! I don’t understand why people get so crazy about negative reviews on their favorite books. There are some people here on WordPress that I talk to frequently who have bashed books that I love and I don’t mind whatsoever. Everyone has different tastes. Whenever I’m looking to read a new book, I go straight to the negative reviews to see if they wrote about things that I know are big pet peeves of mine. I think negative reviews can be really beneficial if they’re done the right way. 🙂 My intent isn’t to discourage anyone from reading that book, I’m just stating why I, personally, didn’t enjoy it.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Erika says:

        Same goes for me. I love well thought out negative review where the reviewer gives constructive criticism. If they make great points and their reasons aligns with what I hate in books then I usually will put off reading that particular book. If a reviewer just says do not read it, it’s’re going to need more than that to convince me why it’s terrible. I am actually more eager to read a badly reviewed book because I want to see for myself if it’s really true..(yes it’s true most times) but I like to form my own opinion on it.
        And yes when I write a bad review on a book my intention is not to discourage readers to read it which I think are some people’s mindset when they read one (the ones who love the book anyways). I would actually like it when they read the book and decide it for themselves because I want to know what they though t of it. It kind of annoys me when people get so upset with you when you hate a book that they love.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Exactly! It’s like they get so upset that they can’t see beyond their own anger. Even some of the best books ever written have bad reviews. That’s just to be expected. Everyone has different tastes, experiences, and reactions so it’s not plausible to believe that every person on earth will feel the same away about that book.
        And yes! I especially get annoyed with reviews that will simply say one or two lines such as, “I’m not even going to waste my time reading this book because I already know I’m going to hate it” and then they rate it one star which I found totally unfair to the author.

        Liked by 1 person

      3. Erika says:

        Generally people are so irrational. I mean it’s just a bad review of a book. Relax. HAHA

        Oh my gosh I know what you mean! Yes some books could definitely be a waste of time, but you can’t honestly hate a book without even really reading it. Another thing I hate is reviews that is more of rant than a constructive criticism. This is why I am not as easily swayed by reviews especially on Goodreads. If I really want to read a book regardless of the bad reviews I will still read it. I honestly don’t care what anyone says. lol

        Liked by 1 person

      4. Right?! If I DNF a book, I won’t even rate it unless I was close to the end. I think it’s the right thing to do considering that I didn’t even finish it.
        Oh yes! I read one the other day that was a rant. I can’t remember exactly what it was about, but a girl kept going on and on about her values and how the book went against her beliefs. I thought it was weird to complain about it since it explicitly said that’s what the book was about in the blurb. I mean it’s not the book’s fault that she didn’t read the blurb lol
        I’m exactly the same way lol I might still read a book if the blurb is really interesting or if the cover is really pretty even if the majority of people said they hated it lol.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Jessica says:

    I hate when reviews personally attack the author but other than that, I think negative reviews are perfectly fine. When I’m writing negative reviews (even 1 stars) I always leave some sort of positive feedback. For example, maybe the writing was good, or there was this one particular character I liked. There’s usually something! Great post. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Exactly! I feel bad if it’s just all negative so I try to lessen the blow by adding something good. Thank you so much! 🙂


  3. Lola says:

    Great post! I review every book i read and also write negative reviews, in my opinion as long as you write a good review and don’t personally attack the author there is no reason to get attacked. I always try to emphasize on thigns beign my opinion and say what I did and didn’t like.
    While it still hurts when you never hear back form the author again or get an unhelpfull vote on amazon. I feel like I can’t adeautely show what I do and don’t like when I don’t review those books I didn’t like as well. I also review books that I DNF, but don’t review them on the blog as I often only write short reviews and don’t put as much work in them. I don’t like DNF’ing books or writing negative reviews and am often a bit afraid of sending the author my review, but I want to be honest and will emphasize what I did and didn’t like in my reviews. Great post!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you! 🙂 And I completely agree! I also write short reviews for books I DNF, but I don’t rate them. I only give my reasons for not being able to continue with it. It can be a little tricky at times.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s